Britain could be in for a rough ride with the Oxford-AstraZeneca jab, but there’s no need to panic
No one should panic, but we need to brace ourselves for a difficult week or two as regards the Oxford-AstraZeneca vaccine.
On Tuesday, Germany became the latest in a growing list of countries, including Canada and France, to suspend use of the vaccine in younger age groups. In Germany the cut off is 60, while in Canada and France only those age 55 and above are now receiving the jab.
Unfortunately, the issue is no longer political and is unlikely to be batted away as such.
Germany’s medical regulator announced on Tuesday it had received a total of 31 reports of rare blood clots in recent recipients of the AstraZeneca vaccine. Nine died and all but two of the cases involved women aged 20 to 63, the Paul Ehrlich Institute said.
Based on the data available at the time, the European Medicines Agency (EMA) concluded there was not enough evidence to establish a link between the problem and the vaccine, and recommended it continue to be used. The benefits of inoculation greatly outweighed the risks for all age groups, it stressed.
The problem now is that more data is flowing in.
On Tuesday, a team of European researchers published a not-yet-peer-reviewed preprint which looked at nine patients in Germany and Austria who developed thrombocytopenia and clots following vaccination.
“The AZD1222 vaccine is associated with development of a prothrombotic disorder that clinically resembles heparin-induced thrombocytopenia but which shows a different serological profile”, they said.
Not surprisingly, regulators in the UK, Europe and North America are now all racing to better understand if an association between the jab and the condition really exists and, if so, at what rate it occurs.
It is this second part of the puzzle which will prove crucial as all medicines carry some risk. The real question is whether or not the benefits will continue to outweigh the risks.
According to UK data, the risk of someone between 18 and 49 being taken to hospital after becoming infected with the now dominant UK variant of Covid is around 1,200 in 100,000 (1.2 per cent). The risk irrespective of infection status stood at about a third of that over the last year.
Even with new cases of blood clotting being reported, it seems unlikely the AstraZeneca vaccine could present a greater threat than this.
The relevant clotting data from Norway put the risk at about four in 100,000 and the German figures put it at just over one in 100,000.
But even if the risk of vaccination continues to be trumped by the risk of Covid, will it be enough given there are alternative vaccines to choose from?
“The argument I keep hearing is that the risk-benefit ratio is still positive. But we do not have just one vaccine, we have several”, Sandra Ciesek, a virologist at Goethe University, Frankfur told Science magazine this week. “So, restricting the AstraZeneca vaccine to older people makes sense to me, and it does not waste any doses.”
That is essentially the call Germany, France and Canada have made this week but it may not be as easy for the UK which is more reliant on the AstraZenica jab, for the moment at least.